Mar 09‘The instinct to protect their young’

Ruth Kluger's memoir, "Still Alive"

Ever since she turned 12 years old in 1938, my mother suffered with a profound sense of rejection because her parents chose to send her to safety in America. Throughout her life, my mother continued to see this act through the lens of a child. She felt her parents didn’t love her enough to keep her in Germany. She didn’t blame Hitler for her situation; she blamed her parents and, until she was in her late sixties, she believed they had betrayed her.

Ironically, a woman named Ruth Kluger harbored similar resentments towards her parents, though they had made a very different choice. In her book, Still Alive, A Holocaust Girlhood Remembered, Kluger recounts that her parents had rejected the opportunity to send her on the Kindertransport to safety. Kluger’s parents believed that “a child and its mother belong together.”

Decades later, Kluger reports in her book that their decision shows that her parents lacked the primal instinct to protect their young. By keeping her in Vienna, Kluger felt her parents had  betrayed her.

Mar 04A Foot in Two Worlds?

I read this quote this morning: “To emigrate is to become a foreigner in two places at once.”

Or to emigrate can mean living in two places at once. As I wrote in Motherland: “Memory for most is a kind of afterlife; for my mother, it is another form of life…For her, scenes from decades ago had their own immediacy. Her inner life is schizophrenically filled with both the here and now and the there and then.”

And, in time, living in two places at once can lead to a deeper sense of alienation within the family. After she had married an Israeli and moved to Israel, an American friend of mine once said: “I didn’t realize that when I married someone from another culture I would produce children who would be foreigners to me.”

A foreigner with foreign children, in two places at once.

Mar 02Giving baseball immortal Hank Greenberg his due

The Jewish Babe Ruth, "Hammerin' Hank"

Baseball star Hank Greenberg is a small but significant character in my new book, “Is It Night or Day?”

The book, based upon my mother’s experiences, captures Edith’s immigration in 1938 and her assimilation into American culture. Frightened, isolated, and ridiculed in her new environment, Edith finds solace in baseball.

At that time, Comiskey Park offered free admission for women on Thursdays (Ladies’ Day), and Edith was introduced to America through the games. Hank Greenberg, the Jewish slugger for the Tigers, emerges as both a role model and surrogate father for Edith.

Greenberg, one of the premier power hitters of his time, hit 58 home runs in 1938. The American League twice named Greenberg the Most Valuable Player and he was a five-time All Star player.

Harvard law school professor Alan Dershowitz says that Greenberg was “the most important Jew of that period, giving hope to all the others through his accomplishments, allowing them to think that they could fit into the mainstream. He was articulate, a great player, a great role model, had a great work ethic, and though not a religious Jew he realized how important his heritage was and how others looked up to him to do what is right.”

Though he was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1956, Greenberg still lacks the recognition he deserves, and my hope is that this novel will help address his relative obscurity. In Is It Night or Day?, Hank Greenberg and baseball give Edith, who has suffered terrible losses, a glimpse of hope for the future

Feb 27A home and a place in history

Searching for a metaphoric home

Pulitzer-prize winning novelist Carol Shields once said that “a great novel should follow the character’s search for a metaphoric home.”

I’ve thought a lot about that comment recently; it resonates with Is It Night or Day? in two ways.

First, that is the trajectory of Edith’s story. She is a child immigrant searching for a home, physically and metaphorically. Young Edith’s bewildered efforts to assimilate in America are as poignant as her struggle against constant feelings of abandonment and isolation. Through the prism of Edith’s story, readers experience urgent themes that resonate with today’s headlines: families torn and children threatened by immigration issues, war, natural disasters, and the daunting work necessary to rebuild a life in the face of unspeakable loss.

Second, with the book’s launch only weeks away, the book and the story are searching for a home and an audience. The book explores the little-known One Thousand Children project which rescued some 1,200 youngsters from the Holocaust.

My hope is that this book will give Edith a home and the One Thousand Children a place in history.

Feb 24Baby picture!

DSCN2106

It’s a book!!!

In bookstores March 16th.

Feb 22PW: ‘Well worth reading’

Is It Night or Day? Fern Schumer Chapman. Farrar, Straus, & Giroux, $16.99 (192p) ISBN 978-0-374-17744-7

Chapman, who wrote about her family’s Holocaust ordeal in the adult book Motherland: Beyond the Holocaust, assumes the voice of her mother, Edith, who at age 12 is sent by her Jewish parents from increasingly anti-Semitic Germany to live in America with relatives. Edith’s plaintive narration describes her father’s mounting fear of the Nazis (“suddenly, we were filth, Jews polluting the village,”) and her mother’s increasing detachment. The story of Edith’s ocean voyage to America provides some light moments; without her parents around, Edith’s fears and anxiety are always evident, but her interactions with other young Jewish emigrants are touchingly childlike, such as when they play hide-and-seek onboard. In Chicago, Edith is met by a disdainful aunt who treats her like a servant and classmates who keep their distance. Though her story reads more like a memoir than a novel, Chapman captures a plucky determination in Edith that readers will find endearing. There is no Cinderella ending for Edith, but the hope she finds in Jewish ballplayer Hank Greenberg and the honesty in her story make this historical fiction well worth reading. Ages 10–up. (Mar.)

Feb 19Of emigrants and immigrants

A memorial statue in Hanko, Finland, commemorating the thousands of emigrants who left the country to start a new life in the United States

The definition of immigration is “a person who comes to a country to take up permanent residence or a plant or animal that becomes established in an area where it was previously unknown.” But the concept can encompass much more and much less than that.

Immigrating connotes coming to a new place while emigrating connotes leaving. My mother actually emigrated from Germany, but is it fair to say she immigrated to America?

That implies that there was some pull to this country. She did not share the spirit of those who left shtetls in Russia or Poland for America in the 19th century. They believed the streets were paved with gold, but nothing pulled my mother to a new country. She was only 12 years old when she emigrated; she wanted to remain in Germany with her parents.

In the process of emigrating, my mother also became an immigrant in another aspect of her life. As she entered adolescence, she sought meaning and coherence, mirroring every young person’s journey from childhood to adulthood.

A broad interpretation of immigration would include children entering adolescence since they are introduced to “an area … previously unknown.” It also would include adults who, say, leave an unhappy marriage, as they are coming to a new “country to take up permanent residence.”

Through major life changes, we are both emigrants and immigrants.

Feb 17‘I feel like a thief!’

housebig

My mother's childhood home

Most Germany homes are handed down from one generation to the next. My mother’s childhood home in Stockstadt had been in her family for 200 years. But after the Holocaust, Nazis stole some Jewish homes; others became available for rent.

In the Kreis-Gross Gerau area, one family who rents a former Jewish home has lived uneasily in it since 1978. “We wondered what happened to the original owners,” the tenant told me.

The man who grew up in the home fled Nazi Germany for Palestine in 1936. When he returned for a visit when he was 79 years old, he told the residents that his brother and sister escaped, but his parents were killed in the Holocaust.

“It was strange when he was here because this was his house, his birthplace, the place of his youth,” the tenant said. “He stood for a moment on the last step of the stairs. It was emotional for him.

“I felt terribly guilty. I know that there is no reason to think it, but I felt like a thief.”

In 2000, my mother’s cousin returned to his home in Worfelden and told this story: “Early one morning, I went to the house where I was born so I could take a picture. As I held up my camera, a man stepped in front of me and asked, ‘Why are you photographing my home?’ ‘Well,’ I said, ‘it used to be my home.’ Then he invited me in. Only the attic and the basement were the same. Everything else was different. Then I noticed my cat wasn’t there either.

At that time, my mother and I spoke to the residents who now live in her childhood home in Stockstadt. The couple inherited the home from the man’s father. “We didn’t know this home belonged to your family,” he insisted. “My father never told us anything. We were shocked when we read the German edition of Motherland and learned about the house and your history.”

Feb 13Scars and wounds of the second generation

In another blog entry, I wrote that the second generation has the scars without the wounds of Nazi Germany. But, in his book Child Survivors of the Holocaust, Dr. Paul Valent claims that the second generation has the scars and the wounds.

“Second generation children are dominated by the shadow of the Holocaust without ever understanding the original context,” he writes.”They were in some ways more vulnerable than child survivors because they carried scars and emotions with no possibility of remembering their origin. While they had the advantage of being born in an objectively better world, they were subject to the memories, anguish and struggles of their parents, who often kept them in the dark about them…

“The lack of memories is indeed a lack, a deprivation, because without memories the scars one carries in the form of emotions and behavior are believed to be senseless and irrational. This is because the scars cannot be connected with the original wounds. Further, because there are no words or concepts for the original traumas, they cannot be integrated into higher level views such as of parents, blame and identity…

“The younger the person (who experiences trauma), the greater is their vulnerability, the less their ability to know and to speak, or even to know what they would like to say.”

Feb 11‘I retain all the pain of my grandmother’

The lives of all the Germans I know have been defined by the Holocaust and its legacy. Some more than others.

I have another friend in her 60s whose family has lived in my mother’s town, Stockstadt, for generations. This friend feels terribly alienated because her mother made a choice after she had her only child: She decided she wouldn’t have any more children because she wouldn’t want to send a son to war.

“Now I have no family,” my friend explains. “No one is left.”

Her grandmother worked in a nearby hospital which housed disabled children during the 1930s. “My grandmother was forced (under threat to her life) to prepare the children for the trains. I am like a microchip. I retain all the pain of my grandmother.” (Interestingly, my friend works with learning disabled teenagers.)

Her grandfather hated Hitler and made a remark about it. “After that, he was put in a hospital for the mentally ill. He died there. Her grandmother, who also had been outspoken about Hitler, was very quiet after that and simply did her job.”

My friend’s mother once saw my grandmother Frieda in Darmstadt. At that time, (around 1940) she was living in the Jew house. “Whenever my mother told this story she would cry. She greeted Frieda and she wanted to hug her. But Frieda refused.

“‘You are safe,’ Frieda said. ‘Go away!’”